Public Safety Project™
Promoting effective and efficient public safety policies and exposing counter-productive policies and practices.
Skip to content
  • Home
  • Election Info
    • City Elections
      • El Segundo, CA City Elections
        • April 10, 2012 El Segundo General Municipal Election
        • April 8, 2014 El Segundo General Municipal Election
    • School District Elections
      • El Segundo, CA School District Elections
    • Primary Elections
      • CA Primary Elections
    • General Elections
      • CA General Elections
        • November 6, 2012 California General Election
    • Special Elections
      • CA Special Elections
  • Subscribe
  • Library
  • Videos
  • Compensation Reform
  • Tax and Fee Increases
  • Tools
    • Submitting Letters to the Editor and Opinion Columns
    • Word Counter Tool
    • Links
    • Old Web Site
  • Terms Of Use
    • Legal Disclaimers
    • Terms Of Use / Terms Of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Copyright Notice
    • Trademark Notice
  • About
    • Social Media
    • Mission Statement
    • History
    • Contact Us
← Special Contract – Payment in Lieu of Taxes Agreement Between El Segundo and Chevron
Special Email – FW: Note attachment – Threatening Note Doug Willmore said he found on his car windshield →

Special Email – RE: Chevron Chamber Package – 1-4-2012.pdf – Adobe Acrobat Standard

Posted on January 9, 2012 by Mike

From: Giordano
Sent: Monday, January 09, 2012 9:22 AM
To: dwillmore@elsegundo.org
Subject: RE: Chevron Chamber Package – 1-4-2012.pdf – Adobe Acrobat Standard

Thanks for note; will not forward. Mary

Mary Giordano
Assistant City Manager – Office of the City Manager
City of Torrance | 3031 Torrance Boulevard | Torrance CA 90503 | 310.618.5880 voice | 310.618.5891 fax |
MGiordano@TorranceCA.gov | www.TorranceCA.gov


From: Willmore Doug
Sent: Saturday, January 07, 2012 4:49 PM
To: MGIORDANO@TorranceCA.gov
Subject: FW: Chevron Chamber Package – 1-4-2012.pdf – Adobe Acrobat Standard
Attachments: Chevron Revenue Analysis.pdf

Mary,

This is an email I sent to my Council and I’m sending it for background. Please don’t forward the email on or quote it in any way.

Doug


From: Willmore, Doug
Sent: Wednesday, January 04, 2012 6:58 PM
To: Busch, Eric (Mayor)
Subject: FW: Chevron Chamber Package – 1-4-2012.pdf – Adobe Acrobat Standard

All,

Attached is a comparison of Chevron’s refinery in El Segundo to the other five largest refineries in municipalities in CA. The ES refinery is the largest (by volume) in the state of CA. As you can see, by almost any useful measure or ratio or method of comparison, the tax revenue we receive from Chevron is far below those of other refineries in other cities in CA.

You should know that before I had decided to present revenue per acre as one of the ways to evaluate Chevron’s tax burden, I spoke to a couple of people who I trust who are knowledgeable about local tax structures. They were my brother Brad, an investment banker in the SF Bay area, and Darrin Casper, my CFO at Salt Lake County. Brad used to do energy deals for Solomon Brothers on Wall Street and has done more than 15 utility or oil and gas mergers or acquisitions of up to $5B and knows the business inside and out — especially how they pay their taxes. Darrin used to do energy financing for oil and gas deals for the firm Lewis Young in the investment banking world before becoming a CFO. Both Brad and Darrin suggested to me to use revenue per acre as not just one way to analyze Chevron’s local tax structure, but as THE best way. Brad and Darrin both said comparing one refinery to another is useful, but not as useful as comparing this refinery to other land uses in your City.

As you know, when constructing a revenue collection system for any public entity, the fundamental criteria has to be fairness and equity. That is the reason that both Brad and Darrin suggested the revenue per acre comparison. I’ll get into the additional reasons why they said so in the next paragraph.

Since December 20, I’ve also spoken with lead analysts at Fitch, Moody’s, and Standard & Poor’s – all analysts that I used to present reguarly to while I was at Salt Lake County. They all are lead analysts for the State of California and for many of its cities, counties, and school districts. And, I also spoke with the Director of Public Finance for Zion’s Bank, a regional banking firm in the west that acts as financial advisors for public entities who are heading to the market. Zion’s Bank is the FA for Salt Lake County. All four endorsed the use of revenue per acre or something similar as a valid and valuable method to attempt to construct a fair and equitable tax structure in El Segundo. All four people that I spoke with concurred that the existing system is extemely unfair. In fact, one of them said that if we were presenting to them that he would grill us over “the issue” and ask us when it was going to be fixed. He said he would ding our rating because our structure was so unfair unless it was going to be fixed because it puts the sustaining revenue of the city at risk.

The analyst at Fitch said our tax structure sends this message: “If you need square fottage and people to produce a profit we tax the hell out of you, but if you need acreage and a big machine to produce a profit, you’re home free.” The analyst at S&P was quite scathing about our tax structure and said not only is it unfair, but it’s “dumb public policy”. I asked him why, and he said, “Because you’re taxing the businesses that can move, and the one that can’t move is getting special treatment.” He said it’s the worst kind of public policy, wherein Northrup Grummin, Raytheon, DirecTV and others are taxed as they expand and Chevron can add infrastructure to increase their volume and they pay nothing for their expansion. They all said that Chevron’s acreage and infrastructure should be viewed comparably and taxed comparably to our aerospace community.

Having said that, local tax structure in CA is far more subjective than in other cities in other states, so it is a judgment call. Nevertheless, if you leave aside the comparison to other acreage in El Segundo and just compare this refinery to the others in the state, you could double what Chevron pays us and they would still be the lowest in all the ratios.

Thought you should have this information.

Doug

Note by Michael D. Robbins on March 23, 2012:

Imposing business tax revenue per acre standards is extremely unfair, impractical, and counter-productive for multiple reasons as explained in Are Chevron’s Taxes Too High?” by Michael D. Robbins, at http://publicsafetyproject.com/blog/2012/03/16/are-chevrons-taxes-too-high/.

This entry was posted in El Segundo Chevron Public Records Act Request and tagged Chevron, Doug Willmore, El Segundo, email archive, gas, local government, Mary Giordano, oil, Public Records Act request, shakedown, special email, Torrance. Bookmark the permalink.
← Special Contract – Payment in Lieu of Taxes Agreement Between El Segundo and Chevron
Special Email – FW: Note attachment – Threatening Note Doug Willmore said he found on his car windshield →
  • Social Media


    Twitter:


    CLICK HERE to Tweet this page.

    CLICK HERE to go to the Public Safety Project Twitter page (@PSP_USA).
    @PSP_USA

    https://twitter.com/PSP_USA


    YouTube videos:


    CLICK HERE to go to the Public Safety Project YouTube video web page.
    PublicSafetyProject

    http://www.youtube.com/user/PublicSafetyProject


  • ALERTS


    CALIFORNIA ELECTION ALERT !


    Tuesday, September 14, 2021 is Recall Election Day in California.

    Vote YES on the first question to RECALL GOVERNOR GAVIN NEWSOM; and

    Vote for LARRY ELDER on the second question to elect Larry Elder as governor if a majority of the votes counted voted Yes on the first question.


    Vote-By-Mail ballots were mailed out to ALL registered voters, dead or alive, moved out of the state or not, legal or illegal. This was done to maximize the opportunity for election fraud and theft to keep Governor Gavin Newsom in office.

    The election fraud can include stuffing the ballot box with fraudulent ballots voting NO on the RECALL and NO VOTE for the new governor, and destroying, discarding, or not counting ballots voting YES and LARRY ELDER.

    You can vote by mail, but it is probably safer to vote in person at the election poll on or before September 14, 2021 to help ensure your vote gets counted.


  • GREAT WEBSITES TO VISIT REGULARLY:

    Prager U
    Dennis Prager's 5-Minute Educational Videos
    Free Videos. Free Minds. www.PragerU.com

    KRLA AM 870 Talk Radio
    AM870TheAnswer.com

    KABC AM 790 Talk Radio
    www.KABC.com

    Mark Levin Radio Talk Show:
    www.MarkLevinShow.com

    Hear or download past shows for free:
    www.MarkLevinShow.com/audio-rewind/


  • Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • WordPress.org
  • January 2012
    M T W T F S S
    « Dec   Feb »
     1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    3031  
  • Recent Posts

    • Recall Racist and Undemocratic Governor Newsom, Elect Larry Elder – Letter to the El Segundo Herald by Michael D. Robbins
    • America’s Founding Principles in 250 Words, Including the Title
    • Former El Segundo City Councilman Mike Robbins Exposed Evidence of an El Segundo Unified School District Pay-For-Play Scam Involving Bond Measure ES
    • Flyer Distributed throughout El Segundo exposing evidence of El Segundo Unified School District Pay-For-Play to Fund School Bond Ballot Measure ES Campaign
    • Alert for the Tuesday, November 8, 2016 General Election
  • Recent Comments

    • Why “Hate Crime” Laws are Immoral and Counter-Productive, by Michael D. Robbins | Public Safety Project™ on Hate Crime Law Supporters Weakened Our Criminal Justice System and Self-Defense Rights, by Michael D. Robbins
    • El Segundo firefighter Michael Archambault arrested at Costco for allegedly shoplifting five products worth $354.95 (Booking Photo) | Public Safety Project™ on Could Firefighter’s Arrest be the Result of a Culture of Entitlement?
    • Special Email – RE: Chevron Chamber Package – 1-4-2012.pdf – Adobe Acrobat Standard | Public Safety Project™ on Are Chevron’s Taxes Too High?
    • Special Email – FW: Chevron Chamber Package – 1-4-2012.pdf – Adobe Acrobat Standard | Public Safety Project™ on Are Chevron’s Taxes Too High?
    • Eye-Popping El Segundo 2009 City Employee Compensation Data Now Available | Public Safety Project on Eye-Popping El Segundo 2009 Firefighter Compensation Data
  • Archives

    • August 2021
    • June 2021
    • November 2018
    • August 2016
    • May 2016
    • April 2016
    • March 2016
    • December 2015
    • November 2015
    • October 2015
    • September 2015
    • August 2015
    • July 2015
    • January 2015
    • October 2014
    • June 2014
    • May 2014
    • April 2014
    • March 2014
    • February 2013
    • November 2012
    • October 2012
    • September 2012
    • August 2012
    • July 2012
    • May 2012
    • April 2012
    • March 2012
    • February 2012
    • January 2012
    • December 2011
    • November 2011
    • October 2011
    • September 2011
    • August 2011
    • July 2011
    • June 2011
    • May 2011
    • March 2011
    • February 2011
    • January 2011
    • December 2010
    • October 2010
    • September 2010
    • August 2010
    • January 2010
    • October 2009
    • April 2008
    • August 2005
    • August 2004
    • April 2004
    • August 2001
    • July 2001
    • April 1996
    • March 1996
    • January 1994
    • November 1991
  • Categories

    • 9-11 Terrorism Attack
    • ALERTS
    • America's Founding Documents
    • America's Founding Principles
    • American Founding
    • ATM Machines
    • Babies
    • Banking
    • Beach Reporter Letters
    • Birds
    • Bombings
    • California
    • Crime Control
    • Crimes
    • Daily Breeze Letters
    • Declaration of Independence
    • Democrats
    • Doug Willmore's Great Chevron Shakedown
    • Doug Willmore’s Great City Shakedown
    • Economy and Economics
    • El Segundo
    • El Segundo Chevron Public Records Act Request
    • El Segundo Election Coverage
    • El Segundo Herald Letters
    • El Segundo Hotel Transient Occupancy Tax (TOT)
    • El Segundo Measure B TOT Tax Hike
    • El Segundo News
    • El Segundo Tax and Fee Increases
    • Elections
    • Elections
    • Environment
    • Ethics
    • Fake News
    • Federalist Papers
    • Firefighter and Police Union Compensation and Pensions
    • Firefighter Union Corruption
    • Firefighters Commiting Crimes
    • Fraud Waste and Abuse
    • Genocide
    • Government Employee Compensation and Pensions
    • Gun Control
    • Hermosa Beach
    • Historical News
    • Humor
    • Identity Theft
    • Individual Liberty
    • Islamic Terrorism
    • Israel
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Library
    • Los Angeles Times
    • Manhattan Beach
    • Manhattan Beach News
    • Mass Murders
    • Measure A – 5 New Taxes and 6 Tax Inceases
    • Measure P – Firefighters Union Initiative
    • Middle East
    • News
    • Police Officers Commiting Crimes
    • Police Union Corruption
    • Political Corruption
    • Politics
    • Position Papers
    • Public Records
    • Public Records Act
    • Recall Election
    • Recall Election
    • Redondo Beach
    • Research
    • RKBA
    • School Teachers Union Corruption
    • Security
    • Self-Defense
    • Self-Defense and Gun Rights
    • Tax Policy and Issues
    • Terrorism
    • U.S. Constitution
    • Uncategorized
    • Union Corruption
    • United States
    • Videos
    • Violent Crime
    • Weapons of Mass Destruction
    • Wildlife
  • Pages

    • About
      • Contact Us
      • History
      • Mission Statement
      • Social Media
    • Compensation Reform
    • Election Info
      • City Elections
        • El Segundo, CA City Elections
          • April 10, 2012 El Segundo General Municipal Election
          • April 8, 2014 El Segundo General Municipal Election
      • General Elections
        • CA General Elections
          • November 6, 2012 California General Election
      • Primary Elections
        • CA Primary Elections
      • School District Elections
        • El Segundo, CA School District Elections
      • Special Elections
        • CA Special Elections
    • Library
    • Subscribe
    • Tax and Fee Increases
    • Terms Of Use
      • Copyright Notice
      • Legal Disclaimers
      • Privacy Statement
      • Terms Of Use / Terms Of Service
      • Trademark Notice
    • Tools
      • Links
      • Old Web Site
      • Submitting Letters to the Editor and Opinion Columns
      • Word Counter Tool
    • Videos
  • Blogroll

    • Documentation
    • El Segundo Police Officers' Association (ESPOA) Exposed Response to the El Segundo Police Officers’ Association City Council Endorsements El Segundo Police Officers' Association (ESPOA) Exposed Response to the El Segundo Police Officers’ Association City Council Endorsements
    • Pension Tsunami Unfunded pension liabilities and excessive and unsustainable government pensions threaten bankruptcy.
    • Plugins
    • Suggest Ideas
    • Support Forum
    • Themes
    • WordPress Blog
    • WordPress Planet

  • CLICK HERE to Tweet this page.
    CLICK HERE to go to the Public Safety Project Twitter page (@PSP_USA).
    CLICK HERE to go to the Public Safety Project YouTube video web page.


  • Copyright © 1999-2021 by
    Michael D. Robbins and the
    Public Safety Project™.

Public Safety Project™
Proudly powered by WordPress.