What is a Fire or Police Union Endorsement Really Worth? by Michael D. Robbins

The following flyer was distributed city-wide to homes throughout El Segundo in advance of the Aril, 2008 El Segundo city election, on Sunday, April 6, 2008.

You can view a PDF version of the flyer by clicking on either of the two document thumbnail images below.

                                               


EVERY VOTER SHOULD READ THESE FACTS

ABOUT REAL PUBLIC SAFETY IN EL SEGUNDO !

A public service of the El Segundo Public Safety Project – PublicSafetyProject.Org

For supporting documentation, additional and updated information,
and responses to any last-minute hit-pieces, be sure to visit our web site.


What is a Fire or Police Union Endorsement Really Worth ?

El Segundo Fire and Police Union bosses have unilaterally endorsed candidates:

  1. With the Worst public safety and spending records.

    In the last City Council election (2004), the El Segundo Fire and Police Union
    Bosses
    endorsed the candidates with the worst public safety records and failed to
    endorse the two candidates with outstanding public safety records – Jim
    Boulgarides, a firefighter and paramedic in another city and also an L.A. County
    Lifeguard – and former multi-term Mayor Carl Jacobson, who was instrumental in
    the successful relocation into El Segundo and modernization of our 911 emergency
    call/dispatch center and our public safety records management system.

    The Union bosses endorsed George Nakano for our State Assembly district in
    2002, even though Nakano voted only three days after the 9-11 Terrorist Attack
    to give official California driver licenses to Illegal Aliens, Identity Thieves, Drug
    Smugglers, and Terrorists using the identity of their choice (AB 60, 9/14/2001).
    Nakano voted for dangerous laws and bloated budgets that led to the Governor
    Davis recall.

  2. With the Worst integrity records.

    In the last City Council election (2004), the police and fire Union bosses endorsed
    the three candidates supported with tens of thousands of dollars from outside
    special interests, including developers, a trash hauler, someone who tried to obtain
    a large city contract without competition, and others who may have expected
    something in return. One of these candidates was Eric Busch. Busch has received
    large contributions from someone who tried to rig the competition for a large city
    contract and have it awarded to a less qualified bidder at nearly twice the price.

    The $50,000 plus election campaign with many $1,000 to $6,000 contributions
    was highly unusual for small town El Segundo. Campaigns used to cost less than
    $5,000 and a lot of shoe leather. Although the Union bosses and outside special
    interests out-spent the independent candidates by as much as ten to one, they won
    only one of three council seats – Eric Busch.

  3. (continued)


    (continued)

  4. Without allowing the Union members to meet the candidates and vote on
    endorsements. The Union bosses decided amongst themselves, and then “flowed
    down” their decisions to the Union members.
  5. POLITICAL CORRUPTION?

    The police and fire Union bosses claimed in many election campaigns that we will get
    better and faster emergency service if we vote for their “approved” candidates, i.e., worse
    and slower service otherwise.

    The fire Union bosses even claimed there was “the possibility of our paramedics not
    being available when you need them” if Eric Busch, Sandra Jacobs, and Bill Fisher were
    not elected to City Council in the last city election (2004). They made this claim in their
    disgraceful “Senior Scare” letter, which they sent to senior citizens throughout
    El Segundo on official fire Union letterhead, and signed by all three Union bosses on
    behalf of El Segundo firefighters and paramedics, without allowing them to vote on it!
    A scan of this letter can be viewed at PublicSafetyProject.org/elsegundo.

    The El Segundo Union bosses met with at least some city council candidates for this
    Tuesday’s election, to discuss their pay and benefit increases in the upcoming labor
    contract negotiations
    . We value our high quality police and fire services and personnel.
    However, salaries should be competitive, and based on the law of supply and demand and
    the true value of high quality personnel in a free economy. The El Segundo firefighter
    and police salaries are the highest in the region, and probably among the highest in the
    state and the country. Excessive salaries and benefits means less money for staffing,
    equipment, and training, reducing personnel and public safety.

    POSSIBLE INTIMIDATION?

    The police and fire Union boss endorsements are intimidating some residents and
    business owners who perceive an implied threat that emergency service may be delayed
    or absent, or they may be harassed, if they do not support the candidates approved by the
    Union bosses. These concerns are amplified by California Government Code section 845
    which states, “Neither a public entity nor a public employee is liable for failure to …
    provide police protection service or … to provide sufficient police protection service.”

    Is this the right direction for El Segundo?

    Of course not! The first step to promote public safety in El Segundo is to elect honest and
    competent candidates who represent the residents and tax payers, and not the Union
    bosses
    and outside special interests. Only independent candidates who are not beholden
    to Union bosses can maintain quality and efficiency in our police and fire departments,
    and be fair to residents, tax payers, and city employees in all departments.

    PLEASE NOTE: The Union bosses do periodic fundraising to replenish their political campaign accounts.
    These are not charitable contributions. Get written evidence of tax deductibility before donating to any charity.

    Authored and Paid for by Michael Robbins, El Segundo Public Safety Project, P.O. Box 2193,
    El Segundo, CA 90245. Not authorized or endorsed by any candidate or committee. Rev. 04/02/08

This entry was posted in California, El Segundo, El Segundo Election Coverage, El Segundo News, Elections, Firefighter and Police Union Compensation and Pensions, Firefighter Union Corruption, Government Employee Compensation and Pensions, News, Police Union Corruption, Political Corruption, Politics, Union Corruption and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.